mrxak, on Mar 1 2008, 12:27 PM, said:
I don't mind the senate or the plot, but 1-3 haters should actually watch 4-6 sometime, and realize it's all crappy acting and mostly action. Jar Jar haters should take a look at C-3PO from 4-6 as well. 1-3 were great because we actually got to see real lightsaber fighting. That's all Star Wars is really about, and 1-3 delivered.
I couldn't disagree with you more, I'm afraid. While Luke was always a little lacklustre in 4-6, the Leia/Solo pairing was brilliantly done, and was not matched by any comparable acting in 1-3. By comparison, the acting in 1-3 tended to be pretty wooden, particularly the love scenes, where there was zero chemistry. And I'm afraid that Jar Jar was an obnoxious stereotype, while 3-CPO formed part of a fresh and amusing comical duo.
No, the original Star Wars was about a lot more than action and explosions, which is why 1-3 fell flat. The unbelievably awesome Yoda fight scene (and other cool choreography) can't make up for the deader-than-Diana acting that plagued the prequels.